Most small businesses don't need a CFO on day one. Plenty never do. But there's a point where a bookkeeper and a once-a-year visit to your CPA stop being enough, and most owners only notice it after a surprise tax bill or a cash crunch.
Here are nine signs it's time to think about when to hire a fractional CFO. For each one, there's also a "not yet" signal, so you can tell whether you really need the help.
1. You run the business from your bank balance
You check the account every morning to decide what you can spend. You don't really know what next month looks like until you're in it.
Not yet if: cash is consistently comfortable and your spending rarely changes.
2. You're profitable on paper but cash feels tight
The P&L says you're doing well, but you still feel squeezed. That usually means receivables, debt payments, owner draws or taxes are pulling cash out in ways your reports don't show. (We break down the seven usual causes in Profitable but Broke?)
Not yet if: profit and cash line up month after month.
3. You don't know how much to set aside for taxes
This is one of the most common reasons owners call us. Dr. Monica Mathews Dayanand, founder of Fertile Moon Integrative Medicine, told us her practice was growing fast but she "could not have told you what I was spending or how much to set aside." A simple set-aside plan and a monthly check-in changed that.
Not yet if: your CPA has given you a set-aside percentage and you actually follow it.
4. Your books are behind, or you don't trust them
If you're months behind, or the numbers "feel off," every decision you make rests on bad information. Captain Fred McBride, who owns a seafood restaurant, said the books "were always the last thing on my list." Getting them built properly was step one.
Not yet if: the books close every month and you trust them. (If they don't, start with catching up on bookkeeping.)
5. You're thinking about hiring
A new hire is a long-term cash commitment. Can the business carry the cost for six months before the new person pays off? A hiring model answers that before you make the offer.
Not yet if: you're not planning to add anyone this year.
6. A big structural decision is coming
S-Corp election, moving contractors to payroll, a second location, a new loan: these decisions touch taxes, payroll and cash all at once.
Lauren Pitts of Tidier Spaces faced two at the same time, an S-Corp election and a move from 1099 contractors to W-2 employees. Working through them with us, she said, "gives us a level of peace of mind we didn't even realize was possible."
Not yet if: nothing structural is changing in the next 12 months.
7. Back-office tasks are eating your best person's time
When payroll, reconciliations and reporting land on one person, that person stops doing everything else. At Talyard Brewing Co, payroll week (tips, off-cycle checks, hours out of the POS) was the biggest worry in the back office. Handing it off gave the back office manager her time back.
Not yet if: your back office runs smoothly with time to spare.
8. You're growing faster than your systems
Growth uses cash before it produces cash. If revenue is climbing but you feel less in control, your finances haven't caught up with the business.
Not yet if: growth is steady and your reports still answer your questions.
9. A lender, landlord or partner is asking for numbers you can't produce
When a bank asks for financials, or a partner asks about margins, and pulling the answer takes a week, you're missing finance infrastructure.
Not yet if: you can pull clean financials in a day.
How many signs is "enough"?
- 0–1 signs: a good bookkeeper and your CPA are probably enough for now.
- 2–3 signs: a light-touch engagement, such as monthly books plus a monthly review call, is often the right step.
- 4 or more: you'll likely benefit from forecasting and regular planning support too.
What happens next
If you're seeing several of these signs, you don't need a full-time executive. A fractional CFO works with you part-time, alongside your existing CPA and bookkeeper, using the software you already have.
At Forney Consulting Group, ongoing engagements start at $500 per month, and the first call is free.
Book a free 30-minute call with Billy. Bring your list of signs, and we'll tell you honestly whether you need us yet.