Profitable but Broke? 7 Reasons Your Cash Is Missing

By Billy Forney · · 4 min read

Your profit and loss statement says you had a good month. Your bank account says otherwise.

If your business is profitable but has no cash, you're not imagining it and you're not alone. Profit and cash are two different things. Profit measures whether you earned more than you spent on paper. Cash is what's actually in the bank today. The gap between them can be big enough to keep you up at night.

Here are seven of the most common reasons, each with a quick check you can run yourself.

1. Customers haven't paid you yet

When you send an invoice, most accounting setups count it as revenue right away. But the cash doesn't arrive until the customer pays, which might be 30, 60 or 90 days later.

5-minute check: In QuickBooks or Xero, run an A/R Aging report. Add up everything older than 30 days. That's profit you've earned but can't spend.

2. You're paying down debt

Loan interest shows up on your P&L as an expense. Loan principal doesn't. It's paying off a balance, not a cost. So a business with an SBA loan can look comfortably profitable while a big chunk of cash goes out the door every month.

5-minute check: Find your monthly loan payment and subtract the interest portion. The rest is cash leaving that your P&L never shows.

This is also why loan records matter. One of our restaurant clients, Captain Mc's Blue Crab and Fish, carries an SBA loan. Keeping balances and payments matched to the bank every month is part of what gives the owner an accurate picture of what the business really makes.

3. Owner draws and distributions

Money you take out of the business as an owner (draws or distributions) usually isn't an expense, so it doesn't reduce profit. It does reduce cash.

5-minute check: Total your owner draws for the last three months and compare them to net profit for the same period. If draws are higher, you're spending more than the business earns.

4. Taxes you didn't set aside

Profit creates a tax bill, but that bill often arrives months later as a quarterly estimate or a lump sum at filing time. If you spent the profit, the tax payment comes out of cash you need to operate.

Dr. Monica Mathews Dayanand, founder of Fertile Moon Integrative Medicine, described this well: her practice was growing fast, but she couldn't have said how much to set aside, and taxes kept her up at night. A simple set-aside plan, reviewed monthly, turned that worry into a routine.

5-minute check: Do you have a separate account for taxes, and does it hold a set percentage of profit? If not, start one. Your CPA can help you choose the percentage.

5. Inventory and prepaid expenses

Buying inventory, or prepaying a year of insurance, uses cash today but only shows up as an expense later, when the goods are sold or the months go by. Restaurants and retailers feel this constantly.

5-minute check: Compare inventory on your balance sheet this month to three months ago. If it's climbing faster than sales, cash is sitting on your shelves.

6. Growth eats cash

This one surprises people. Growing usually costs cash before it makes cash. You hire before the new revenue arrives, buy more inventory, and wait longer on more invoices. The faster you grow, the bigger the gap.

5-minute check: Look at your last hire or expansion. How many weeks passed between the first cost and the first new dollar of revenue? That's your growth gap.

7. Payroll timing (especially with tips)

Payroll is often your largest expense, and the timing rarely lines up with when revenue lands. For restaurants, bars and breweries, tips, off-cycle checks and POS exports add more moving parts.

At Talyard Brewing Co in Sugar Land, Texas, payroll week used to be the biggest worry in the back office. Once we took over payroll end to end, with tips, off-cycle checks and hours from their Arryved POS all built in, payroll became predictable, and predictable payroll is far easier to plan cash around.

5-minute check: Put your next three payroll dates on a calendar next to when your big deposits usually arrive. Any week where payroll lands before deposits is a pinch point.

How to stop being surprised by cash

Each check above finds a gap. The fix for all of them is the same: look forward, not just back.

A 13-week cash flow forecast maps the cash coming in and going out, week by week, for the next quarter. Receivables, loan payments, draws, tax set-asides, inventory buys and payroll all go in. You see the tight weeks before you reach them. We walk through it step by step in How to Build a 13-Week Cash Flow Forecast.

If your books aren't accurate enough to forecast from yet, start with catching up on bookkeeping.

When to get help

If you ran these checks and found more questions than answers, that's normal. Most owners never had anyone show them how profit and cash connect. That gap is exactly what a fractional CFO closes.

Book a free 30-minute call with Billy. We'll look at where your cash is going and what to do about it, with no obligation.

← All articles