"Why would I need a CFO? I already have a CPA."
It's the question I hear most, and it's a fair one. Bookkeepers, CPAs and fractional CFOs all work with your numbers, so they can sound interchangeable. They aren't. Each one answers a different question about your business, and knowing the difference is how you avoid paying for help you don't need or missing help you do.
The short version
- Bookkeeper: What happened? Records and organizes every transaction.
- CPA: What do we owe, and are we compliant? Handles taxes, filings and compliance.
- Fractional CFO: What happens next? Uses the numbers to forecast and guide decisions.
Side-by-side comparison
| Bookkeeper | CPA | Fractional CFO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main question | What happened? | What do we owe? | What's coming, and what should we do? |
| Looks | Backward (transactions) | Backward (tax year) | Forward (weeks and months ahead) |
| Typical work | Recording transactions, reconciling accounts, monthly close | Tax returns, tax planning, compliance, audits | Cash forecasts, dashboards, hiring and growth models, decision support |
| How often | Weekly / monthly | Quarterly / annually | Monthly, with on-call support |
| Output | Accurate books | Filed returns | A plan and the numbers behind it |
| You need them when… | You have transactions (always) | You owe taxes (always) | Cash is tight, decisions are big, or growth is fast |
What a bookkeeper does
A bookkeeper keeps the record straight: every deposit, bill, payroll run and loan payment goes in the right place, and the accounts match the bank.
This sounds basic, but it's the foundation for everything else. Captain Fred McBride, who owns a seafood restaurant, came to us because the back office "was always the last thing on my list." Before anyone could talk strategy, his books had to be built from scratch, with every Toast deposit and payroll run tied back to the bank.
Without good bookkeeping, your CPA and your CFO are both working from bad data.
What a CPA does
A CPA (certified public accountant) is licensed to prepare tax returns, give tax advice, and handle compliance. Most CPAs working with small businesses focus on filing season and tax strategy.
What CPAs usually don't do is meet with you every month to forecast cash, build a dashboard, or tell you whether next quarter can support a new hire. That isn't a failing. It's simply not their job.
Important: Forney Consulting Group is not a CPA firm and doesn't replace your CPA for tax filing. We work alongside your CPA.
What a fractional CFO does
A fractional CFO takes accurate books and turns them into decisions:
- How much cash will we have in eight weeks? → a 13-week cash flow forecast
- Can we afford this hire? → a hiring and runway model
- How much should I set aside for taxes? → a tax set-aside and savings plan (coordinated with your CPA)
- Should we change how we're structured or paid? → decision support, again working with your CPA
Lauren Pitts at Tidier Spaces is a good example. As her organizing business grew, she faced an S-Corp election and a move from 1099 contractors to W-2 employees. Those decisions touch taxes, payroll and cash all at once. Having someone to coordinate them, as she put it, "makes complex financial decisions feel manageable."
How they work together
In a healthy small business, the three roles hand off to each other:
- The bookkeeper closes the month accurately.
- The fractional CFO reviews the results with you, updates the forecast, and flags decisions coming up.
- The CPA uses clean books to file accurately and advise on tax strategy, often with better information because the CFO has been tracking set-asides all year.
In many small-business engagements, one firm covers both bookkeeping and the CFO role. That's how most of our clients work with us: the books and the forward-looking guidance come from the same place, and we coordinate with your CPA at tax time.
Which one do you need right now?
Just a bookkeeper if your finances are simple, cash is steady, and no big decisions are coming up.
A bookkeeper and a CPA if you're in that position and also have a tax return to file. That's most businesses.
Add a fractional CFO if:
- You're profitable on paper but cash still feels tight (why that happens)
- You don't know how much to set aside for taxes
- You're weighing a hire, a loan, a new location, or an entity change
- You're growing fast and the numbers aren't keeping up
Dr. Monica Mathews Dayanand of Fertile Moon Integrative Medicine had a bookkeeping problem and a CFO problem: messy books, plus no plan for taxes as her practice grew. Fixing both, with a monthly call to review the numbers, is what finally made her feel "in control of the business side of my practice."
Frequently asked questions
Can a fractional CFO do my taxes? Not at Forney Consulting Group. Tax filing belongs with your CPA. We keep the books and set-asides ready so tax time is simpler.
Do I need to replace my bookkeeper? No. We can work alongside your existing bookkeeper, or take bookkeeping over if that's simpler for you.
Do I have to switch accounting software? No. We work with QuickBooks, Xero and spreadsheets.
Not sure what you need?
Tell us where things stand and we'll tell you honestly which kind of help fits, even if it isn't us. Book a free 30-minute call.